Woodworking vises

[capt jake]

I picked up two nice woodworking vises the other day for a song. Being as I have never actually had one to use (always improvised with a meta working vise) I need some advice. Is there really any need to install two of them on a bench? I am contemplating selling one to recover the investment of both of them.

Is one typically sufficient or should I install them both?

[Arnie Eaton]

I have two wood vises on my work bench. The trouble with them is where I mounted them, one on the end and one on the side. Should have placed both on the same side to hold long stock.

[capt jake]

Well that was one of the questions I was pondering. I was going to place them as you describe, though maybe I will put them on the same side.

Any real need for two of them?

[Arnie Eaton]

99% of the time you will only use one. Two is really redundant and if you don't really need but one, sell the other one. A clamp can sometimes be used as a vise in a pinch, like clamping one end to a sawhorse while the other end is in the bench vise.

[Kudzu]

I guess the answer is "it depends".

I have two on mine and use them both. But I have my bench set up for the two.

As you can see, I use an old leg vice on the front but it could be a regular vice too. I have a sliding deadman on the front to support the end of longer boards. As it's name implies it slides in a dado and the support is held in place by a couple of dowel pins. So I could put a wide board up there if I need.

My table has dog holes in it that line up with the end vice. I attached a large block with a dog hole to the vice. I can clamp boards flat on the bench to work on. After using this bench for a few months now I love it and can't imagine not having a proper bench to work on.

If I were to build another I would build it with the two vices setup like this one. I find them extremely useful and use both of them all the time. But you may work different them me and this might not suit your work style.

[Greg Luckett]

Dog holes is what them holes in the top are called, eh?

Ok, I see how a peg used in conjunction with the vise would fix a board.

Did you use a plan for somewhere to build the bench?

Thanks.

[Charlie Jones]

I use the shoulder vise on mine (on the front) the most but the end vise is useful also. Put in a row of dog holes down the bench. then you can clamp stuff between the vise and a bench dog to plane, sand etc.

[ulpilotrmh]

How does one post photos with a reply? I tried to add them in a reply to this thread, but got an error message. Is it because this is such an old thread? Would I be able to post the photos if I started a new thread?

[Greg Luckett]

I use both of mine, most often to try a different positions, but on larger pieces, both are usable for clamping the piece to the bench.

[ulpilotrmh]

Okay, here goes another attempt to teach my self to post photos to a thread. This is my Emmert Patternmaker's Vise. They haven't been made since the 1960's, but are available on eBay for a few hundred dollars. If you had one, you'd agree it was money well spent. There is a modern smaller, made in China or Thaiwan knock off available from Woodcraft.