Jump to content

BS 1088 Occume plywoods


Guest Oyster

Recommended Posts

Guest Oyster

Well this is more of a FWIW post for most folks but thought I would share this one with you folks. You will need to double click on the pictures to get the jest of the story. But both woods are the same material and speced out B.S. 1088 standards, but one with the label is 5 ply and the other is 7 plys. Of course I am using the seven ply, 9mm. But do ask when buying the wood, even though it may carry the 1088 label.

post-0-129497649088_thumb.jpg

post-0-129497649096_thumb.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites


Why is the occume better than meranti other than the weight issue? Seems odd that a panel made from a less durable species that costs more.

The meranti from world panel had no stickers but a red inked stamp. I ordered in 2 lots,6 months apart and the wood was nearly identical. 9mm had 7 plies. I know you guys are the experts but trying to make a choice on which to get was rather troubling.

Have you tried meranti Oyster,anyone else?What did you think of it?Was it a bad choice on my part?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Occume has a definite advantage if there is a lot of shape because it will bend more easily and will make more of a bend before it will snap. For brightwork Occume also has a much nicer appearance than Hydrotec, and it is also lighter. It certainly does have it uses, but for most applications the Hydrotec is the better value. If a boat is built with the proper "WEST" construction there is not the durability issue with other forms of construction.

---Joel---

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Any chance that there is some counterfeit stuff floating around?

Try going to Mexico and buying a real Cuban Cohiba. You can buy cigars all day long with Cohiba labels, but very few of them are Cuban.

What do the suppliers like Edensaw or Noah's say about it when the stuff turns up different?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Did some review of some of my saved sites. This one has some relative information:

http://alliedveneer.com/index.html?utm_source=google&utm_medium=ppc&utm_campaign=marineplywood

Note the difference between the Aquatec and Hydrotec products. Perhaps some of the shipments got crossed up? And also note the color of the Joubert label.

What is Meranti in relation to Luan? This site says these are Luan based products, but later describes them as Meranti.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

What is Meranti in relation to Luan?

I have wondered that myself. My personal feeling is that Luan is a 'catch all' term for a whole slew of species. Kind of like 'mohogany'. My personal feelings only. With that said, it would seem that Meranti is a family within the 'Luan' catagory.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Well- first, Okume is NOT a mahogany- it's an african hardwood called "Okume" strangely enough.

Luaun as I understand it, is Phillipine Mahogany, which technically is in the cedar family, so it's also NOT a true mahogany in reality.

Don't know about Meranti, although when I was building my trimaran in the late 70s/early 80s, the company I was buying my Western Red Cedar flitches from also sold flitches of Meranti. This was NOT plywood- it was 1/8 inch thick veneers, for use in cold molding. They were flitch cut and could be obtained in long lengths, pretty much the same as the WRC.

Yesterday I picked up some Okume by the way- Shellmarine stuff. BS1088, Lloyld's certified- 6MM with 5 ply. It's also not 4 by 8. It's 49 1/4 by 98 1/2 inches. When you scarf it you wind up with a useable 4 by 8 after lapping.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest Oyster

I understand the difference of Occume and Luan when it comes to rcognizing grains. My original point was more on the issues of veneers, which adds strength, but also the quality of woods or plywoods in this case, when it comes to high end and low end. Even some of the common plywoods, used in home construction comes, with thick and uniform plys, unlike the common filled woods of the 9mm five ply Occume plywood with the B.S. 1088 stamp on it. I do not know the color difference in the stamp face, but the two are different even in the insides. The five ply came from another antique job.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The meranti smells different than the luan. The meranti smells just like a cigar box and from what I heard,cigar box wood was thought to be spanish cedar. The room that I kept it in smelled like a cigar box,when I cut it,even more so.

The one question I have never been able to get clearly answered has to do with the thinner outer veneers. On standard construction plywood,with most of it's veneers the same thickness,is a consideration when arranging the sheets in relation to the framing.The grain on the outer plies makes the sheet stronger in rip direction or it's length across frames or joists or whatever. Is this maybe why that some marine panels are said to bend funny? Is the last thicker veneer just under the outer thin one's grain going across the width of the sheet? If this is the case,it would seem that this could add to that starved horse effect of a plywood planked,framed boat?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Meranti is different from Lauan. Lauan is an Indonesian cedar and is now referred to as "Philippine Mahogany" primarily because of color and some grain similarities. Meranti is a cousin of the mahogany family, though more often then not, is now lumped into the "Lauan" group, which can include a number of different woods from that part of the world. Meranti once was the "Indonesian Mahogany" and quite nice stuff. For some unknown reason it's often categorized with the Lauans. Manufacturing controls and grading system usage, swings from reasonably good to none at all in many western rim countries, particularly China, the lot of south east Asia and the Philippines. Careful inspection of all plywood from these areas, especially if a "Philippine mahogany" is ordered.

Sapele is an African mahogany, typically with a wider grain pattern then other mahoganies, it also finishes very well and has good rot resistance. Okome is another African species, but not related to the mahoganies and it's properties have been pointed out.

Thinner outer veneers are a result of a finishing process after the panel is assembled. Construction grade ply doesn't need a high level of finish, so the outer layers are about the same thickness as the inner. On marine grade ply, the outer layers are machined quite smooth, which removes a portion of the thickness. When assembled these sheets had equal thickness layers. Cabinet grade panels have a paper thin layer of veneer applied, with much thicker inner layers. These sheets require only the aesthetic qualities of the outer veneer, not the structural properties, so the manufactures don't waist stock (the nice veneer) in a product that doesn't need it. Cabinet grades, typically don't have WBP glue and can't be used in a boat, unless used as a drawer front, for which it was designed.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I guess my point was more to the effect that if both outer plies were thicker with the grain running longitudally,or even if the 4 plies of a 7 ply panel's grain was orientated in that way,their characteristics would be closer to that of a solid wood plank with it's grain running the same way from a bending in a curve across frames standpoint.Maybe that would make a difference in it's bending characteristics as well. I just don't know if this is an engineering consideration when designing a panel for marine grade or other kind of construction panel.

If when sheeting in a floor and you are a piece short and your only drop has the grain of the outside skins running the wrong way,even if it fits, it will be a soft spot between the joists compared to a drop with the grain facing the proper direction.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest Oyster

Its hard to discuss the characteristics of every plywood, when you talk about bending and strength. There are two combinations that you should always look for in plywood. The inner plies need to be uniform in thicknesses, and have odd numbers of plies. This is not always the case.

You will find this to be one of the main reasons for bending problems along with weak plywood. The types of cores are sometimes not whats on the face, either. Some of the inner cores are not continuous cores, meaning seams and fill wood can exist. In that seam, there can also be a tiny void, that also lets go in that longitual bend, and cross grain orientation, allowing for the sudden snapping sound. In most cases, attaching the name "marine" to the plywood, may give you the proper glues, but may not give you good plywoods. Some of the hardwood faced plywoods, are pretty crappy, because some cheaper priced stuff use cores that are sold throughout the world for laminating single veneers and sold to the industry. In a lot of these plywoods, there is not a resorcinol glue in the inner layers, either.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Oyster....back to your original post:

Any chance that the stuff you thought was 1088 is actually the 6566?

http://www.edensaw.com/product_detail.asp?p_id=268&cat=3&gr=11

3/8 Okoume in the 6566 grade has 5 plys. Have not been able to find a picture of the Joubert label for the 6566, but that may be where the difference comes from.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest Oyster

The stamp says right on it as being B.S. 1088. I did not purchase the plywood, in question. The lot was part of a surplus bunch of wood, given to me. But the hull that that this plywood is in, requires the thickness, which in conjunction with the plies, gets part of the integrity of the hull from the laminates. Its only skinned with finish cloth, which gives it no real strength, or its my opinion. I am very specific and scrutinize every single sheet I place inside a hull that carries with it any form of liability with others using the boat besides myself.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Point taken about the core issues as well. I didn't have bending issues with the ply I purchased but I remember at one point before buying it and researching feedback to the different brands/types, I had read where some said meranti bent funny. Maybe this isn't even an issue on a fair curved lapstrake boat with next to no twist or compound twisting of a panel and being the wood was used 7" wide rips instead of trying to torture a wide piece on a slab sided hull.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 weeks later...
Guest Oyster
Occume has a definite advantage if there is a lot of shape because it will bend more easily and will make more of a bend before it will snap. For brightwork Occume also has a much nicer appearance than Hydrotec' date=' and it is also lighter. It certainly does have it uses, but for most applications the Hydrotec is the better value. If a boat is built with the proper "WEST" construction there is not the durability issue with other forms of construction.

---Joel---[/quote']

Just being of a curious nature, I purchased four sheets of Hydrotek 1088, 9 mm. Since I will still be using the 1088 Okume, I wanted to compare the two for the same applications. I have never been that happy with the 6566 Meranti, but I am always open for discussion in our ever changing world.

I applies the same scarfing methods to the four sheets and have glued them up now. As far as the weight issue, a single sheet is about 8 lbs plus or minus, more in weight and the cores are not as nice and uniform when hitting it with the same tool, my reliable Milwalkee 6,000 with 24 grit on it. Its surely stiffer than the 1088 Okume.

I know that using this method is not PC, but thats the way I do it here, in this production setting. I the finish it off with either a RO or a belt sander with fine grit on it.

While the Okume sands true, the Hydrotek had some issues with following true, but nothing that can't be worked out in the finish end of it.

While I do not recommend such harsh treatment for the occasional guy, I have learned to control this beast and accomplish this job in abour six minutes of work time.

Here is my results. I do back up the wood with numerous sheets and in lieu of this, at least use a soid board under the edge across the end of the plywood for stiffness when doing do.

post-0-129497649655_thumb.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Nothing wrong with doing things like that. I can't even begin to tell all the field joints I dressed with the milwaukee 9" on large steel pipe to be welded. My forearms should be the size of my legs although not being the case, that 9" made them feel like it at times.

I'm sure somehow, that your scarfs turn out fine as I doubt you would bother with the method if they didn't. Some people have that favorite "do all" tool and mine happens to be, in my trade, the milwaukee sawzall. The cubs are pretty amazed I can weild that rascal with one hand while steadying the pipe with the other or cut a perfect cope or scarf on pipe with one.

Would I try your seemingly crude method for scarfing plywood? Heck yeah. The stripes left from the contrasting plies are a good indicator of squarness. Surely it has to be better than fussing around with all those hat trick jigs and the tools needed to work them. Especially if you are trying to make a living at it.

Thanks for showing that.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...

Supporting Members

Supporting Members can create Clubs, photo Galleries, don't see ads and make messing-about.com possible! Become a Supporting Member - only $12 for the next year. Pay by PayPal or credit card.




×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use.