Jump to content

Learning to Sail (again?) (Spindrift 11N)


Recommended Posts

tl;dr: Looking for learning resources for non-competitive dinghy sailing.

 

Hiya folks! So I’ve pretty much finished my Spindrift 11N. Her name is Elsewhere and she is red and white and wonderful. I’m sailing on the Hudson River off Lower Manhattan (Pier 40 is home). The Hudson is fun! Salty, a little icky, and a lot ferry. We play chicken, me and the ferries and the party boats and the giant barges. Never a dull moment.

 

I learned to sail and practiced on a 22-foot-ish bermuda rigged sloop on a quiet little “river” (more of a long lake, really). Elsewhere is much more skittish and “active”. And less forgiving of errors. Like getting the mainsheet caught on a life vest attachment during a tack. That got me in the water right quick, and the fire fighters dropping by to see what the fuss was about. I’m learning all about the nuances of downwind sailing on a boat without shrouds and how crucial line management and tidiness is.

 

So the question: are there books or other learning resources for the “beginner” cat rigged dinghy sailor? Not particularly interested in racing, but looking to hone the craft of safe and confident sailing. (My heart rate is apparently consistently two to three times higher on the boat than on land =D )

F3CAA6A0-75C1-4FBE-BEF2-6CF192DE7938.jpeg

BC667A6C-01A5-4DB5-9284-E1B69837A48E.jpeg

Link to comment
Share on other sites


@Aleksandr Pasechnik— I have found that experience is the best teacher.  Also, I suggest using YouTube.  I’d search under Laser sailing techniques.  If you have specific questions especially related to the Spindrift, this forum would work.  I’m not aware of any books that would help.  But YouTube is great for this.  Here’s an example.  

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Wow, big water and little boat.  I've seen what those currents can do, so you are right to be cautious.  Do you have the ability to move your boat over to City Island?  I've never been there, but I know it's much more congenial to learning small craft.  And there's at least 2 sailing schools and clubs there.  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 weeks later...

Unfortunately the Messabout this year falls on a day that I recently got some much anticipated concert tickets for. Also, I would imagine I'd have to rent a U-Haul to get Elsewhere down there =D . But I'll take a look at some of these videos you linked and suggested. The Spindrift is close enough to the Laser for the techniques to apply?

 

I really like having Elsewhere down at Pier 40 because it's a short bike ride away. Moving her up to City Island would unfortunately result in almost 2 hours of busses and trains to see her!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I believe the Laser has more things in common with the Spindrift than things that are different.  Granted, the toll tack video was a poor choice.  But there are many “basics and beyond” on YouTube; most lessons are in a Laser.  Here’s Part 1 of a good series.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 1 month later...

Went through the MIT sailing course and a bunch of videos on Youtube.

 

The thing I still can’t find a good reference for is depowering when heading downwind. In other points, I can generally loose the mainsheet if things get too squarely but when heading downwind there’s only so much one can do, no? Am I not “by the lee” enough? Is there a limit to how far forward I can send the sail? Should I instead be thinking about turning up to the wind a bit? Or some non-mainsheet adjustments?

 

I’ve had a few times when heading downwind felt like barely controlled chaos, between the waves and the wind, and it really wasn’t pleasant.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Why do you want to depower?

 

If it is an issue with wind and waves, then don't go dead down wind.  Tack down wind, that is, sail at 135° TWA and gybe back and forth. There will be little or no tendency to roll when off the wind a bit.  If you can plane the boat, it will actually be faster than 180° down wind.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Alek

 

I think you have raised a valid point.  When the wind is up I have always felt more comfortable sailing close to the wind, you do have the waves crashing and the spray but as Amos said you can just head a few degrees up into the wind, feather a little until a gust has past, or heave to and reef.

 

Downwind is another story. when the wind is light no problem, when the wind builds I feel a little panicky because you have to commit  yourself and the safety of pointing up into the wind seems a long way away. Daves advice is sound but a little from the perspective of a racer. 

Quote
18 hours ago, Hirilonde said:

Why do you want to depower?

 

He has a point though. If you want to improve your sailing and push the limits at some point you have to embrace the chaos and go for it. Many times I have found the boat to be much more capable than I thought. 

Quote
On 9/27/2021 at 11:30 PM, Aleksandr Pasechnik said:

Am I not “by the lee” enough?

I am not following you here. My understanding of sailing by the lee is to have your sail on the windward side of the boat when you are running before the wind. In a cat ketch putting the mainsail by the lee keeps both sails in clear air and gives you more power.  Letting the sail out forward of the mast is not sailing by the lee. On my Spindrift the gooseneck will not allow the sail to move forward of the mast.

It is good if there is someone to have your back. Or you can reduce sail. 

Thanks for bringing up some interesting points. Let us know how it goes.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Quote
On 9/27/2021 at 11:30 PM, Aleksandr Pasechnik said:

Am I not “by the lee” enough?

I did a search on the web. I did not realize how much information there was on the advantages of sailing by the lee in a cat rigged dinghy. That is sailing on a run with the boom on the windward or 'wrong' side of the boat on the verge of a gybe. About the only time I sail my Spindrift by the lee is when I am maneuvering around something and I don't want to gybe and than gybe right back when I resume course.  For me sailing by the lee takes a lot of focus. I would not feel comfortable sailing by the lee in winds much above 10 knots.   I use the technique that Dave suggested of varying my TWA to find something that feels comfortable with the wind speed and waves I am dealing with.

Thanks for bringing this up. I am looking forward to experimenting with this technique.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Sailing by the lee is a pretty common trick while racing Lasers to keep your advantage of being on starboard tack or avoiding a couple of gybes at the leeward mark rounding. That said, it can be pretty risky in shifty wind conditions and I've capsized plenty of times when it went wrong. Downwind death rolls are just part of the fun when club racing, especially when the stakes are pretty low.

 

I'm not as willing to risk capsizing in my Spindrift 10n with the family on board, or when there's a lot of traffic in the marina. Or just getting cold and wet for that matter.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I think Graham recommends sailing the main by the lee and the mizzen on the "regular" or downwind side when running wing on wing, which I realize is a little different matter.  That way you get the full effect of the by-the-lee arrangement on the biggest sail.  Like others, I would feel most comfortable with this in light to moderate breezes.  Or reefed.

 

Don't forget the alternative to a heavy wind-gybe, the "chicken gybe," or heading up and tacking around through 270 degrees.  I do this on the big boat when going solo and seeking to avoid a crashing boom all standing.  I would certainly consider it for the CS in heavy wind.  You'd have a chance to take a breather in the middle, too, heaving to.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 3 weeks later...

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share



  • Similar Content

    • By Aleksandr Pasechnik
      I've had a few situations now where I'm in unsteady waters and want to be able to switch my Spindrift 11N to rowing. I've added a topping lift (a simple single line from the top of the mast to the end of the boom) so that the boom doesn't drop into the boat when a release the halyard, but that's proving to be annoying still, since the lift is hard to adjust when there's a breeze and the boom is bouncing around. So now I'm thinking about adding a block to the top of the mast and running the topping lift down and cleating it off with the other control lines.
       
      Part of the goal here is to be able to quickly get the sail out of the way and out of trouble when I need to be rowing. So my theory is that if I add the lift, and then, when necessary, pull the boom way up above my head (30˚ or 45˚ up, perhaps?) then the sail is free to flop and flap about (maybe with some mainsheet tension to keep it towards the back of the boat) but I'd be able to row out of trouble. Is that wrong? Am I liable to end up with a sort of parachute way up in the air knocking my boat around?
       
      Last time I tried to bring the sail down while on the water, the zipper for the sleeve got stuck and then I was bouncing around, and then there was a pier wall, and that was a good 20 minutes of keeping Elsewhere off the wall and upright, pulling myself along to a dock. I'm wondering if a pullable toping lift in conjunction with some kind of line on the sleeve zipper pull would make it easier to get the sail down and out of the way in an emergency. I guess if I'm switching to oars for emergency purposes, I don't really care about getting the sail back up after I'm done rowing to a dock of some kind.
       
      So I guess the question is: how do folks disable, significantly depower, or douse the sleeved Spindrift sail on the water? Do I have to switch to a lashed or rail configuration for the sail? Would raising the sail clew without the ability to mess too much with the other sail controls (with the exception of maybe loosening the halyard and whatever the reefing line can do) make a very tippy boat?
       
      I guess I could also reach the outhaul and the attachment of the reefing line, usually. If I were to replace the bowline knots on their attachments to the boom with some kind of quicker-release knots or pins or something, I could let the whole sail fly free. Maybe add some way of bunching it up to the mast?
    • By ForthBridge
      Hello everyone,
       
      I last posted on here a few years ago.  It's taken me sometime to convince my wife to give up the living room to an N11.
       
      My Spindrift N11 project is called South Queensferry Electron - in recognition of Donald Crowhurst's Teignmouth Electron - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Donald_Crowhurst
       
      Following the usual 'messing-about' convention, here is my progress right up to when I found the courage to saw her in half - earlier today!
       
      Nidaplast is very flexible and I epoxied and peel plied each piece of the hull before assembly.  Bulkheads are carbon fibre and Nidaplast, three layups of biaxial cloth.  A diamond cutting wheel on a Dremmel made short work of trimming excess from the bulkheads and transom.
       
      The hull still needs finishing, as do the bulwarks.  Knees still to fit as well, that's the next job.
       
      So I realise that 6mm ply would have been the best route to go down.  However, prior to this build I had not worked with West Systems or carbon fibre before.  The SQE is a 'learning by doing' project in preparation for the retirement boat.
       
      I will update with more photos as work progresses.  I live in Scotland, the weather is getting colder and less conducive to epoxy use and, of course, I have to give the living room up for Christmas.  Progress might be slow!  However, with the hull complete I can cut out the rest of the Nidaplast components and get the sailing rig ready.
       
      Happy boat building to you all!
       
      Jim
       
       
       






    • By William
      For want of a decent local plywood supplier I will be building in 5mm nidacore honeycomb sandwich, carbon outside, vectran and glass inside. If I can get my hands on some affordable basalt fabric I am sure I will find a few panels for it to feature. It is certainly not going to be as enjoyable as building in wood but at least I will get to learn a few new skills along the way. A lighter boat is almost a guarantee, but that all depends on how many laminates will give me the impact toughness I require. 
       
      I do have a partial sheet of nice 6mm ply and will cut the transom, mast partners and a few other small parts from that.
       
      The nidacore sheets are 7ft x 4ft, which, as fortune would have it, is just long enough to cut the main hull panels from 3 sheets, one being halved and butt-joined to the full sheets just like the plans for plywood.
       
       
    • By Luke
      Hi everyone, this is my first post--I've been lurking here getting lots of good info as I build and finally have a few questions myself!
       
      By now the boat is 3D and wired together. The hull, bulkheads, and transom all seem to fit well, and the boat has no twist in it that I can discern. Measurements from the peak of the bow to the corners of the transom are 109" +/- an 1/8", and sighting down the centerline, the tips of the nesting bulkheads "disappear" below the transom at the same time.
       

       
      I've made a number of spanish windlasses to pull the sides together between the forward and mid bulkhead, to pull out the 1/2" gap between the bottom and the bottom of the nesting bulkheads, to pull the forward bulkhead forward onto its lines, and lastly to try to flatten the bottom seam between bulkheads slightly to close a gap in the bottom panels.
       
      The question is how much of a gap along the keel seam is acceptable? It goes from no gap at the transom and widens to about 1mm around the nesting bulkheads, and up to a maximum of about 3mm halfway between the forward and mid bulkheads. I think the epoxy fillets will cover it just fine, but I just want to make sure it's not a symptom of a larger problem.
       
      Also, the plans don't really give dimensions to make a breasthook or quarter knees--do I just make these to fit the shape of the hull as it stands now? The instructions say the breasthook (included with the kit I suppose) is important to ensure the bow takes the correct shape--so what gives? The sheer lines look nice.
       
      Lastly, I centered the kerf gap of the nesting bulkhead on the "center frame" lines running down the sides--is that correct?
       
      Thanks!
       
       
       
      Additional photos
       
      Looking aft:

       
       
      chine

       
      bow and gap

       
      forward bulkhead

    • By PlaneCrazy
      As my first post on this forum I may as well start a build thread.
       
      I should start out by saying I have little to no experience with boats, but I love building things and my wife says we don’t need any more bookshelves or lawn furniture.
       
      I have read many of the build threads on this site and have appreciated being able to get a more in-depth understanding of the process.
       
      I also watched Alan's set of videos.
       
      So one day I called and talked to Alan, and ordered the kit.
       
      The next thing you know I have a large stack of wood parts, several bottles of epoxy, and rolls of fiberglass tape.
       

       

       
      Onward,
      Mike
       
       
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use.