Jump to content

Alan Stewart

B&B's first annual "Capsize Camp" July, 20-22

Recommended Posts

All good thoughts and thanks for them.


I haven’t seen hysteria in the discussion. Just attempts to get information about the effectiveness of masthead floats. I haven’t capsized my 20 and I hope not to. I intend not to. But I want to be prepared for sailing on the Great Lakes.


My questions have been, Will a float work on a CS 20 Mk 1? How big?


Graham answered the first by saying he would definitely have one on a Mark 1 for sailing distances solo. Thanks. As for size, I guess that is still being kicked around.


I will admit that my preparation has consisted primarily of paying attention to conditions and sailing tactics. Keeping the mainsheet at hand, reefing, watching the gybes, managing weight placement, etc. I could do more with equipment hold downs, attaching righting lines, making sure the masts are sealed, and doing a test capsize. I’ve been negligent in all of that. I do have a boarding ladder.


The mast float is new to me after 45 years of sailing. Never used one. That’s why I appreciate this discussion.

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Good evening, 

Alan mentioned this thread to me the other day and have just had a chance to take a quick look.  A couple of details caught my attention. 

1) Had the centerboard not slid into the well, the boat could have been righted.  Alan's line attached to the board is one way to retrieve the board if it slides in.  Another way to prevent this mishap is to use a preventer line to hold the board down. It is separate line that works opposite the lifting line to hold the board in position. This can be found on Lightnings and flying Scotts that have weighted centerboards.  To do this would take some redesign and probably removal of the cover/ top from the centerboard well.  In general my preference would be a non-weighted centerboard and a way to positively hold it in place. Having capsized lightnings, I am not a fan of weighted centerboards.  In  our boats the  additional ballast does not add a lot of righting moment.  In summary  once a board has slid in, it is difficult, even if not weighted to get it out.  Better to keep the board locked down.

2) I have had at least two friends capsize with inflatable vests, and they could not get back in the boat with the vest on.  They are fine if you don't have to climb back in the boat.  A proper life vest is better. 

3) Jibing.  When it is time to jibe, turn the rudder only 5 degrees.  Pull sails in half way.  The jibe is slow ark.  When the sails get light pull them across the boat. Jibing like capsize recovery, needs practice.  Sometimes they go hand in hand.  Also, death rolling is the result of a vacuum forming behind the sails.  You  can reduce the vacuum by allowing the sails to go forward or to bring  sails in some.  The idea is to let air get behind the sail. 


Finally, our Cs17mk3   is a great boat.  We are fortunate as a group to have designers who are willing to go back to the design board to be sure we can all sail better and safer. 


Best Regards to all. 

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

There was talk about heavier ballasted CBs. My Diabolo("Muckla") has such a thing and I have experience with it.

Originally it had 50 kgs of lead in the lower half, some time ago, I put in another  lump of 10 kgs in so the whole thing weighs 75 kgs on land: 60 kgs of lead + 15of plywood and glassfibre. It is raised and lowered by a simple trailer-winch, that sits under the bridge-deck which is also the cockpit locker. It takes one hand and about 15 secs to get it completely up or down.  So no great chore. Furthermore it has a downhaul (which I sometimes forget to uncleat.....), that prevents the CB from falling into the trunk, should she ever go turtle.

The boat has some internal ballast too, about another 60 kgs, including ground tackle, battery and toolbox.

Recently I have done a heeling test. I hauled her over to about 90 deg. It was really hard to get her on her to something like 60 deg., the rest was easier. When the mast was horizontal, I tied a bucket full of water to the top. It just held the mast down. The bucket contained 12 liters of water, so I guess, the righting force at the mast top was about 10 kgs. I had hoisted the furled Code0 to simulate the weight of the mainsail in addition to the furled jib. This made the test as realistic as it can be single handed. I assume, that, should she ever go close to 90 deg, I would lay on- or straddle the side and thus be somewhere close to the pivoting point. 

All in all, I am very happy with the ballasted CB - unless I have to take it out - or even worse: install it back again.

2019-08-20 14.35.06.jpg

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Not sure whether I should post this here or on Docpal's recent post, but since I've contributed to this thread, figured I'd post here to continue that conversation. Here's what I've come up with for a masthead float. It's 3 24" lengths of  2.75" D pool noodle held in place with a nylon strap, and covered in a dacron sailcloth shroud that mounts to the sail track, in an effort to improve air flow around it (for whatever that's worth).  Had I not miscalculated the volume, I'd have made these 6" longer - or 30" each. By my calculation though, each float currently provides ~16 pounds of flotation, or in the vicinity of 31 pounds total in seawater (I'm Way less bothered about turtling in a lake). Shroud, strap, ledgers, screws and noodles combined for one float weigh a little less than 10 oz.


I haven't yet sail tested the final version, but did sail with a prototype that lacked the shroud around to the mast track. If I had finely tuned racing skills I could offer a more critical review. Lacking that, I couldn't tell any difference in how the boat handled, and it didn't appear to have any effect on the telltales that I could discern. My plan is to simply leave them in place, and not give them much thought again.






This shows fir ledger strips, but I'm replacing them with 1/8" alum strips.




You may notice I'm missing my 3rd batten which is why the sail looks a bit frumpy there.

  • Thanks 1

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

No matter what you put up there, it will be ugly.  There, I said it.


Frowley, that is the least ugly solution I have seen so far.

  • Haha 1

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Dave -  as with most things I've seen you post,  you've got that right!  It's ugly and painful to put it there. I've seen some of your beautiful work. Coming from you I'll take your closing comment as a compliment of sorts. Thanks!

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


Supporting Members

Supporting Members can create Clubs, photo Galleries, don't see ads and make messing-about.com possible! Become a Supporting Member - only $12 for the next year. Pay by PayPal or credit card.

  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use.